Amy L. Farnham

What if we’re not broken?

On thing we’ve embraced as a culture (and that I have wholeheartedly embraced personally) the last few years is the beauty and the power of brokenness. Here’s a quick roll call of some artists of the broken that come to mind for me:

I could go on and on and on. You know that, because I’m sure you can immediately think of someone, too. Pick one you’re familiar with, your favorite story about someone who is broken but/and okay in their brokenness. Think about the person who wrote it, what you admire about them, what is compelling about their story.

Is broken a word you would use to describe them if they hadn’t used it themselves? So many of these stories are about breaking a facade, showing what’s going on behind the scenes. “Because I’m famous/good at something, you may think I have it all together. I don’t.” If they came to you with their stories and didn’t take call it brokenness, would you say they’re broken? Or would you say, “Dang, that’s some messed up shit you went through.”

What IS broken, anyway? What does it mean? Something that is broken is fractured or damaged or no longer in working order. I think of these women, and I think, “Yeah, ok, fractured, damaged… they’re wounded. I suppose you could say that’s being fractured or damaged…” It’s the “no longer in working order” part that catches me. If you think about what they’ve been through… would you expect their bodies and brains to have responded any differently? 

Mechanical gears

The next logical question is this: If admitting that they’ve had a natural (if difficult) response to horrible things in their lives means people are “broken,” what’s the fix? What does working “correctly” look like? Is more resilience to messed up shit really what we want for ourselves as a species?

Why is an acceptance of that messed up shit so deeply ingrained in us that we swallow this narrative of personal brokenness without so much as a hiccup?

Is it because we need to believe that the best we can do about the messed up shit is to get some therapy (if we can afford it) and set boundaries and hope we have the power to enforce them?

Ah, but life is just difficult, you say. Life is hard. Yes, yes it is. There are things that crush us and the reason they happen (if there is one) is lost to mysticism and philosophers. Accidents, earthquakes, hurricanes, deadly viruses. Death is universal, and it sucks.

If you’re old enough, you’ve probably experienced something that left you feeling broken. Fractured, damaged, no longer in working order. If you feel broken, was it one of those things? Or was it something less mysterious in purpose? A human being behaving according to the ways of power and not the ways of love?

What kinds of hurts more naturally fed into a stronger sense of your own purpose, of urgency to live life well in joy? Which hurts gutted your sense of yourself, left you reeling and unstable, sank into your flesh and stayed there festering?


It is true that we only have control over our own actions. I cannot make someone else want to be a good person. Yes, the way of the world is power and injustice…


Do I expect more of myself? Do you? What if there are more people expecting more of themselves than people who do not?

If it’s okay to acknowledge that we’ve been shredded by the machinery of this world that runs on the fuel of power and privilege… Maybe it’s time to be okay with talking about the machine itself, the one that fractures and damages with its working order. Maybe it’s time to do more than look for therapy and gratitude for healing. Maybe sharing our vulnerability and weakness isn\’t an end goal but a starting point for something new. Maybe it’s time for something else to give.

3 Responses

  1. I think the word broken tends to have a negative connotation and is more related to how we’re *feeling* rather than *being*. While we might feel *broken*, I think we are just *falling apart*…like a good jigzaw puzzle. The pieces will always be the same, but everytime it comes undone and you rebuild it, you notice different details of the bigger picture. One time one part of the picture might be easily built, while others, you just can’t figure out where the pieces are. We, too, may fall apart many times, but everytime is a new chance to work on one part of our being. Even when a piece is lost, we hold on to dear hope that one day we’ll find it between cushions or under the rug. Or we let it go with a sigh knowing the dog ate it and just smile. Different things *break* different people, but putting one’s self together, that’s where the reward is.

  2. This goes along with the transition from the evangelical narratives of “personal salvation” and “personal transformation” to a broader notion of God transforming the whole world into God’s kingdom of justice and peace — and using us humans to do it. Maybe the broken-and-remade are the ones who are supposed to change the world? The Beatitudes seem to say as much 🙂

    1. Yep. I have been thinking recently about how much I’ve learned on my journey from God-loving people who have been oppressed more than I have–LGBTQ, BIPOC. There are things I’m realizing about God now that people in those communities have known for years, decades, centuries. I am grateful. And also, the first will be last and the last will be first

Leave a Reply

Join my mailing list for weekly email updates.

Get news about pious magic

%d bloggers like this: